The Best Types of Margaritas For Tequila Lovers in Toronto
The Only Margarita Guide You’ll Ever Need
(a.k.a. your ultimate guide to not wasting a night on a sad, watered-down drink)
Toronto runs on caffeine by day and margaritas by night.
And when that craving hits (you know the one, the “I need salt, lime, and questionable decisions” vibe), there’s only one place that gets it right every. single. time: Papi Chulo’s.
This Mexican restaurant in Toronto is where the drinks sparkle, the tacos slap, and the happy hour crowd turns into your new group chat. It’s the kind of spot where you start with one margarita “just to chill,” and somehow end up at table 12 screaming about 2010s pop songs with strangers.
If you’re serious about your tequila, or you just want to look like you are (hey, we don’t judge here!), here’s your cheat sheet to the best margaritas in Toronto, all found in one gloriously chaotic, flavor-packed place: Papi Chulo’s.
So grab your girls, order some tacos, and let’s go flavor by flavor through this margarita lineup. Because honey, not all margs are created equal.
Classic Margarita: The OG. The Blueprint. The Girl Who Started It All.
If margaritas had a mother, this would be her. Simple, stunning, dependable; the type who never flakes and always knows the best gossip.
Papi Chulo’s Classic Margarita is exactly what it should be: clean lime juice, smooth tequila, and that little agave kiss that makes you hum after the first sip.
Flavor vibes: zesty, refreshing, lime-forward, slightly sweet, the “clean girl aesthetic” of cocktails.
What’s in it: tequila, triple sec, lime, agave, salt rim.
Perfect pairing: Guac & Chips or Al Pastor tacos — because the lime and pineapple combo? A literal flavor duet.
Mood: The first drink of the night, that “let’s catch up” moment.
Hot tip: If it’s your first time at Papi Chulo’s, start here. Classic doesn’t mean boring; it’s the baseline for every tequila adventure that follows.
Spicy Margarita: For the Bold, the Brave, and the Slightly Unhinged
You know that one friend who says “I can handle spice,” and then regrets it halfway through the first bite? This is her drink, but she’ll love every second of it.
The Spicy Margarita at Papi Chulo’s brings that perfect jalapeño heat with just enough citrus to keep things flirty, not fiery. It’s the kind of drink that wakes you up faster than espresso shots at 2 AM.
Flavor vibes: citrusy, bold, and a little chaotic — in the best way.
What’s in it: tequila, lime juice, triple sec, jalapeño slices, chili rim.
Perfect pairing: Birria tacos (for that slow-cooked beef and consomme dunk) or a basket of nachos loaded with queso and jalapeños.
Mood: You’re texting your ex and the group chat at the same time.
Why it slaps: The balance. You get the heat, but the lime keeps it bright and refreshing. It’s dangerous, but make it delicious.
Mango Margarita: Basically Summer in a Glass
If the sun had a flavor, it’d taste like this. Papi Chulo’s Mango Margarita is the ultimate escape-from-Toronto-in-February drink. You could be wearing four layers and still feel like you’re poolside in Tulum.
Flavor vibes: tropical, silky, a little tangy, and dangerously easy to drink.
What’s in it: tequila, mango puree, lime juice, triple sec.
Perfect pairing: Shrimp tacos or ceviche — trust me, the citrus-on-citrus combo is chef’s kiss.
Mood: “Let’s pretend it’s summer and I’m not answering work emails.”
Pro tip: This one hits best during happy hour Toronto sunsets. It’s fruity, flirty, and looks extra cute in a Boomerang.
Peach Margarita: She’s the Main Character of Brunch
If the Classic Margarita is the dependable friend, the Peach Margarita is her fun cousin who shows up uninvited but somehow makes the night better.
It’s juicy, bright, and slightly floral. This is literally the kind of drink that’s never too sweet, but always goes down way too easily.
Flavor vibes: soft, round peach notes with just enough lime to keep it balanced.
What’s in it: tequila, peach puree, lime, agave nectar.
Perfect pairing: Chicken tacos or mozzarella sticks (yes, really). Sweet meets savory, and suddenly you’re a flavor genius.
Mood: Girls’ night pregame. Lip gloss on, playlist fire.
Vibe check: The Peach Margarita is fun but chill. It’s your go-to for catching up with friends you haven’t seen since last summer.
Pineapple Margarita: Tangy and a Whole Personality
You know when a drink tastes so good you forget it’s alcohol? Yeah… this is that drink.
The Pineapple Margarita at Papi Chulo’s is tangy, refreshing, and just tropical enough to trick your brain into thinking you’ve escaped downtown.
Flavor vibes: bright, juicy pineapple with a little tang.
What’s in it: tequila, pineapple juice, triple sec, lime.
Perfect pairing: Grilled fish tacos or spicy chorizo tacos — the pineapple cuts the heat just right.
Mood: You’re dancing before the food arrives.
Bonus points: Order this with a Street Corn on the side. The smoky chili and lime combo? Literal heaven.
Coconut Margarita: Creamy and Dreamy
This one’s for the people who order “one last drink” and somehow end up planning a beach trip at 11 PM.
The Coconut Margarita is smooth, silky, and feels like sipping a tan. The coconut cream gives it that lush, beachy texture, but the lime keeps it from feeling heavy.
Flavor vibes: creamy coconut, zesty lime, soft tequila warmth.
What’s in it: tequila, coconut cream, lime juice, agave.
Perfect pairing: Baja-style fish tacos or tostadas. Trust me, the crisp crunch with creamy coconut = elite combo.
Mood: “I need a break from life” in drink form.
Texture moment: The finish on this one is ridiculously smooth — it’s giving “vacation without PTO.”
Latin Lover: Sweet, Sultry, and a Little Bit Dangerous
This one doesn’t play around. The Latin Lover is Papi Chulo’s spicy-sweet signature. It’s that one drink that makes you tilt your head and go, wait… what’s in this?
It’s fruity, a little fiery, and way too easy to love. Think passionfruit meets tequila with a spicy whisper.
Flavor vibes: tropical passionfruit, spicy kick, zesty lime.
What’s in it: tequila, triple sec, lime, watermelon, spice (yes, it’s got heat).
Perfect pairing: Carne asada tacos or empanadas. The sweet-spicy balance is the moment.
Mood: Flirty. Mischievous. Probably your second favorite drink of the night — because you ordered another.
Signature status: You can only get it at Papi Chulo’s, so bragging rights apply. Check it out on our full Margarita Menu.
Mule the Duck Down: The Margarita That Crashed a Ginger Beer Party
Okay, hear me out: a margarita… with ginger beer?
Yep. And it totally works.
The Mule the Duck Down takes that fizzy Moscow Mule kick and blends it with the soul of a margarita. It’s spicy, citrusy, and ridiculously refreshing. This will surely keep you hydrated and slightly unhinged.
Flavor vibes: limey, gingery, cool, and crisp.
What’s in it: tequila, lime juice, cucumber, and ginger beer.
Perfect pairing: Street Corn or Barbacoa tacos; the ginger brightness cuts right through all the richness.
Mood: “Let’s keep it casual,” but with tequila.
Why it works: It’s light, bubbly, and gives “margarita, but make it interesting.”
One Spot, Endless Margaritas
You don’t need to stumble across half the city to find the good stuff, just plant yourself at Papi Chulo’s and let the tequila do the talking. This place doesn’t dabble in margaritas, it commits. Every glass, from the crisp classic that started it all to tropical, and everything else, feels like a new crush.
And the paired mexican food? Pure chaos in the best possible way. We’re talking Birria tacos that actually live up to the hype, guac that disappears faster than your self-control, and a patio scene that turns golden hour into an unofficial Toronto holiday.
It’s got that downtown happy hour magic, the one that makes you forget what time it is, or that you said “just one drink.” If you’re celebrating, flirting, need to let loose, or simply surviving another Wednesday, Papi Chulo’s is your one-stop shop for joy (and questionable decisions).
Wanna see all the options? Check out the full margarita lineup or book a table before your friends beat you to it. Trust me, they’re already typing “Papi Chulo’s” into the group chat.
FAQs
-
Absolutely. Head to the Contact Us page to book your table or inquire about group events.
-
Yes! Our patio is the place for golden-hour margs and people-watching in Downtown Toronto.
-
Takeout and delivery options may vary depending on what’s available.
-
Don’t Just Read About It. Drink About It.
Look, margaritas aren’t philosophy. They’re therapy — with better lighting.
So stop scrolling like a sad little lime and go get one. Text the group chat (“urgent: margs”). Throw on something that says I might dance later. Then march yourself to Papi Chulo’s, because the only thing worse than a bad margarita… is reading about good ones.
Warning, though: We don’t just serve drinks, we also serve decisions you’ll have to explain in the morning. Every glass hits different. Some make you flirty. Some make you brave. One might make you text your ex, and honestly? That’s between you and the tequila.
Salt the rim. Raise your glass. Make a toast to questionable choices and immaculate taste.
Because if you’re looking for the best margaritas in Toronto, the search is over — it’s Papi Chulo’s, baby. Always has been. Always will be.